Am I Required to Provide a Recorded Statement in an Injury Claim?

recorded statement after an accidentAfter being injured in an accident, you may receive a call from an insurance company requesting a recorded statement about your version of events. Although providing a statement may help speed up the claims process, it could hurt your ability to recover fair compensation for your injuries and damages.

That is why it is important to seek legal help to avoid making statements that could devalue your claim or cause the insurance company to deny it. The experienced lawyers at Sigman Janssen are prepared to review your situation, explain your legal rights, and give you clear and honest answers about your claim in a free consultation.

Why Insurance Companies Want Recorded Statements

Insurance companies have a duty to investigate claims that are made against their insured drivers. They want to get your side of what happened. However, many insurers want a recorded statement so that they can find any evidence to use against you.

They may lead you during the conversation to make damaging statements that make you sound guilty, inconsistent or less truthful or try to use an innocuous statement like “I am fine” against you to suggest that your injuries are not serious as you claim.  

Consequences of Making a Recorded Statement

Most people are not trained to provide guarded yet accurate statements. Unfortunately, insurance companies are aware of this and often try to take advantage of the situation. They may contact you when you are not feeling well and convince you to give a recorded statement.

Accident victims may hurt their claims by:

  • Misspeaking out of nervousness
  • Minimizing their injuries
  • Providing more information than necessary
  • Providing inaccurate information due to lack of knowledge, not understanding the question or being under the influence of pain medication
  • Admitting fault for all or a portion of the accident
  • Committing to an answer that is later disproven by other evidence involved in the claim

Things to Consider If You Decide to Give a Statement

There is no law requiring you to give a statement, whether recorded or not. However, there are certain things you can do to protect your injury claim, should you decide to provide a statement to an insurer:

  • Request that your statement not be recorded
  • Provide concise and factual statements
  • Avoid giving opinions or making guesses
  • It is fine to say “I do not know” or “I do not remember” if this is an honest answer
  • Be truthful even if you think it may hurt your claim
  • Do not minimize or exaggerate your injuries
  • Only answer the question being asked
  • Do not agree to release your medical records by signing a release form

Contact Our Firm for More Information

Learn more about how to protect your rights by contacting a qualified Appleton personal injury lawyer from our firm. We know the tactics companies often use to discredit claims after an accident and are prepared to seek maximum compensation on your behalf.

Our consultations are free and there is no obligation to move forward and no upfront fees unless you are compensated for your injury.

We are here to help. Contact us today at (877) 888-5201.

Reviewed By

James Pitz

Attorney · Sigman Janssen Injury & Disability Lawyers
Licensed Wisconsin Attorney

James Pitz has spent more than three decades practicing civil litigation and personal injury law in Wisconsin, building a career defined by results rather than routine. Since earning admission to the Wisconsin bar in 1993, he has represented over 1,500 clients facing injury, disability, and wrongful death claims, developing a reputation for tenacity against seasoned opposing counsel. He holds a Juris Doctorate from the University of Wisconsin Law School and carries admission to both the Eastern and Western District federal courts in Wisconsin, extending his practice beyond state court. James maintains active standing across the state's leading legal associations, reflecting a career built on sustained engagement with the profession rather than a single credential.

  • J.D., University of Wisconsin Law School
  • Licensed to practice law in Wisconsin since 1993
  • Admitted to the U.S. District Court for the Eastern District of Wisconsin
  • Admitted to the U.S. District Court for the Western District of Wisconsin
  • Member, State Bar of Wisconsin
  • Member, Outagamie County Bar Association
  • Member, American Bar Association
  • Member, Wisconsin Association for Justice